Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Greil Marcus's avatar

To me "The Zebra-Striped Hearse" is part of the great run of Macdonald books--the psychoanalytic mysteries--that peaks with "The Galton Case." But after "The Goodbye Look" it was all stone--and "The Undergound Man" is the first of the dead ones. Paul Nelson spent a lot of time with Macdonald for a Rolling Stone story he was never able to write. When after Paul's death his Macdonald notes and transcripts were edited into a book, you could glimpse why. Macdonald was a victim of early onset Alzeheimer's, and it had kicked in by the time Paul was trying to draw him out. But so, perhaps, had Paul's. You read through the book and you can feel both of them pulling back into themselves, Paul not asking the questions he wants to ask, Macdonald evading almost everything. It's close to unreadable.

When I was in the hospital three years ago, once I began to emerge from the fog of surgery and started to regain some physical function--like being able to sit up or turn over--I started reading. I reread all of Chandler and all of Macdonald--that was all I could handle, and all I could do. I'd reread them all many times before. And I felt, as I sometimes had before, until I read a Chandler paragraph, that Macdonald was steps ahead. I wouldn't go to the firing squad with that. But I'd put a bet down and not mind if I lost.

Expand full comment
Peter Danakas's avatar

Any Columbo where he scampered up and down hidden back hallways and stairs timing himself on his wristwatch to see if the killer had time to commit the murder and escape was always fun. This one also had Dean Stockwell, who was pretty cool. The episodes with Jack Cassidy are my favorites. These columns are always enjoyable.

Expand full comment
5 more comments...

No posts